One more option: IPD sells just the button for $25. Just need to select the correct one. My car is not Geartronic, but the picture of the replacement button that seems most similar is the one for Geartronic with pin.

Thanks Jimmy.

I was able start working on the problem this afternoon. I read from another site that to remove the shift knob, all you need to do is pull up hard on the shift knob. When I did that, the shift knob, boot, and the cover with the gear position indicator all came off.

After reconnecting ...

Hi,
I've searched the forum, and found a lot of issues relayed to shiftlock stuck in Park. I was not able to find a thread related to P2 models that is stuck in Neutral/Drive. The car will not shift into Park nor Reverse, hence, the ignition cannot be turned to the last position to remove the key ...