The last time I bought an OEM muffler, a center muffler weld rusted in four years and the rear muffler interior screen rusted in three years causing the fiberglass to blow out. This doesn't encourage me to pay $850 list ($650 on Black Friday discount) for OEM parts.
This quote from 2018 has haunted me for years. Used original equipment seems like best only solution.
FCP stocks a BRExhaust brand exhaust but it's backordered. I tried the Ferrita stainless and it was too loud for my tastes. Bosal, Starla, and Walker all seem cheap like they'll rust. My local exhaust shop will build a stainless one with a warranty which might be the best bet.
Could the muffler have been damaged by the car running poorly? For instance burning oil, misfiring / passing raw fuel, running rich or lean, condensation pooling water, etc. I know I ask this every time my exhausts rust, but I suspect the cars aren't running well.






