It is a question of principles, and not so much costs as most pulleys are not that expensive ($20-$30/each).
To be honest with you guys, I usually replace pulleys when they get old @ 100K+ miles.
But the other day I was thinking: at 100K miles, as part of maintenance:
- Remove the pulley(s) (TB area has 2 pulleys, serpentine belt area has 2 pulleys)
- Check for any play, if there is play get new pulley, if not...
- Gently pry the seal (yes, if you are careful you can pry it)
- Wash the pulleys in solvent to clean all grease, then dry them under the sun.
- Pack new HD grease
- Re-install the seal properly
In fact, I just re-packed new grease in all the pulleys on my 1998 BMW 528i (grease dried out) and all is quiet now.
Just a thought....







