I guess it really comes down to what you need in your conditions.cn90 wrote:I'd take a FWD car + SNOW tires any day over an AWD with 4-season tires.
I'd invest the money into a set of snow tires.
The AWD feature creates:
- additional cost of maintenance
- additional gasoline cost of about $400 per year based on a 10K miles/year calculation.
I ran All Seasons with AWD for years on my car and I can truly say that
my R with AWD and Triple Treds was a very capable winter car here in Fairbanks.
I had no serious trouble with blowing snow, nasty hills and icy intersections.
Spreading torque over more contact patches makes a huge difference.
I've got plenty of miles on FWD's, RWD's, 4x4's with snows - Studded and non studded.
Most FWD's are essentially one wheel drive lumps with torque steer. You can keep it.
RWD's are fun to drift but come with their own set of problems. 4x4s need the right
size tires. Way too many around here with rubber way too wide - Fun to Watch, though!
( I was lucky enough to spend a few years with an '85 1/2 ton 'burb equipped with tall skinny
Bridgestone X's - That thing was a beast! And it had an unbelievable set of heaters,
but the gas mileage was abysmal...)
AWD P80 - Extra maintenance? Not that much.
More Gas? A little, but you get what you pay for!
Torque steer? Nonexistant.
But why mess around?
Stop by some time and I'll take you for a ride in an R
on our plate ice with AWD and studded Nokians. AWD ROCKS!






